“Trust me, I know what’s good for you.” the mirror said to me sternly.
“I very much doubt that, considering you are just a reflection of me. I am the brains of this operation.” I replied, non-plussed and trying to remember what I had eaten the night before.
“You say that now, but what makes you so sure that you aren’t simply a reflection of me?”
“The fact that I can even think of a response to that proves to me that I am the sentient being here and you are probably the product of my own delusion.” At this point, I began considering calling that therapist after lunch.
“I could say the same thing to you, I’m sure. But really, I think you should listen to my side of things.”
“Alright, fine, I get it,” I said, exasperated, “We’re never going to agree on which of us is the reflection, but humor me for a minute while I explain why this is important. So can we just say that I’m the real one for the time being?”
“Sure sure, go on.”
“Well let’s say one of us is indeed real and the other is a 2D representation. I do believe we have established that, so I’ll move on. With that being the excepted truth, it’s reasonable to also assume that only one of us has a mind and has had all the experiences of life.”
“Yes, what you’re saying is true.”
I continued. “So, with that being said, I can also say that whatever appearance you have is only a superficial copy of the results of my own actions, and I am the only one who has the power to change either of our appearances. Or if you want to take that a little further, I’m the one who has to be able to learn from my experiences and make the best decision for myself. “
The reflection furrowed her eyebrows, which I found strange, considering my own eyebrows were very much not-furrowed.
“You say I haven’t had experiences, that I’m just superficial, but as a reflection -assuming I am your reflection- I have observed things in my own way. Remember, mirrors have been in your life from the beginning. I know the faces you’ve made that no one else has seen. I’ve seen the tears and I’ve heard your monologues when things have been complicated. I even was there when our mother bathed you in the bathroom sink. So, whatever advice I (or you, because I’m still saying that you’re the reflection here) have to give is simply the result of observing your (or my) behavior and reactions over the past 25 years. I think you can agree that would give someone a certain measure of insight.”
After listening to her argument, I fell silent for a few moment. I knew that I was the rational one here, I knew it. As much as I knew it, I started feeling a little…flat. What if my side of things was the product of that kind of observation? Perhaps my knowledge and opinions had come as a response of only the most extreme spurts of emotion and desperation? One of us had to know that there was more to life than defense mechanisms and a reactionary mentality. I was so sure it was me, that I knew what I was doing, but why was I suddenly feeling so confused?
The figure in front of me, whichever side she was on, tilted her head and smiled at me sympathetically.
“I know this must be confusing for you. It’s a little strange for me as well, but that doesn’t change the fact that I know what our path should be. You need to trust me. Trust me that I’ll make the right choice… for both of us.”
I was out of things to say, suddenly my world had begun to seem like a film set.
I choked out a last question in a pathetic and insecure voice. “How can you be so sure it’s you?”
She grinned and softly placed one hand on the glass; I was compelled to do the same. “There is one way.”
I watched her as she turned and in a two steps she was no longer visible in the long rectangle of glass.
And then…I was just….not…